Tuesday, April 17, 2007

Grain Consumption, an Investigation

According to MyPyramid, the new Food Guide Pyramid created by the USDA, a 25 year old male of my height, weight and activity level should be consuming 10oz of grains, half of which should be whole grain, everyday. This amounts to roughly 90grams of carbohydrate, depending on the source, which would constitute 13% of my daily calories, as recommended by MyPyramid. In today's world of endless grain supply, this level of consumption is easily attainable. In fact, I would venture a guess that the majority of us consume far more than our MyPyramid recommended level of grains. Let's face it, a meal just isn't complete unless there is some form of starch in it, and it has always been that way, or at least as far back as written history dictates. Besides, without grains, where would we get all of the carbohydrates that we NEED in our diet for energy?

Without delving deeply into the many reasons why I think that grains are unnecessary, I will instead review Dr. Loren Cordain's research paper "Cereal Grains: Humanity's Double Edged Sword". While the paper is certainly not an exhaustive investigation into the need for grains in the modern human diet, it provides some great insight on the topic.

Introduction

Cordain begins his paper by illustrating just how widespread and overwhelming grain consumption is in the modern world:

....it can be shown that the world’s four major cereal grains (wheat, maize, rice and barley) contribute more tonnage to humanity’s food supply than the next 26 crops combined. Eight cereal grains: wheat, maize, rice, barley, sorghum, oats, rye, and millet provide 56% of the food energy and 50% of the protein consumed on earth.

He uses this data to point out just how dependent man has become on grains, but quickly points out that it hasn't always been that way:

For the vast majority of mankind’s presence on this planet, he rarely if ever consumed cereal grains. With the exception of the last 10,000 years following the agricultural ‘revolution’, humans have existed as non-cereal-eating hunter-gatherers since the emergence of Homo erectus 1.7 million years ago.

Consequently, we have had little time (=500 generations) since the inception of the agricultural revolution 10,000 years ago to adapt to a food type which now represents humanity’s major source of both calories and protein.

This information, combined with the fact that "the human genetic constitution has
changed little in the past 40,000 years"
is pretty compelling evidence to me that grains aren't necessary for optimal nutrition. The most common argument against this line of thinking is that Paleolithic Man led a considerably shorter life than modern man. Thankfully, Cordain covers this in his paper "Evolutionary Health Promotion: A Consideration of Common Counterarguments".

Archaeological Perspective

Cordain traces the origins of grain consumption, where-upon he finds that:

Generally, in most parts of the world, whenever cereal-based diets were first adopted as a staple food replacing the primarily animal-based diets of hunter-gatherers, there was a characteristic reduction in stature, an increase in infant mortality, a reduction in lifespan, an increased incidence of infectious diseases, an increase in iron deficiency anemia, an increased incidence of osteomalacia, porotic hyperostosis and other bone mineral disorders and an increase in the number of dental caries and enamel defects.

This observation has been documented in various sources, including "Guns, Germs, and Steel" by Jared Diamond. Also, as in Diamond's book, Cordain discusses how we wouldn't have been able to sustain increasing population densities without the adoption of grains as a staple food source, since they allowed for social stratification and the ability to abandon nomadic lifestyles:

Cereal grains truly represent humanity’s double-edged sword, for without them we likely would not have had an agricultural ‘revolution’. We surely would not be able to sustain the enormous present-day human population (>6 billion), nor would there likely have been societal stratification which ultimately was responsible for the vast technological/industrial culture in which we live. The enormous increase in human knowledge would probably never had taken place had it not been for the widespread adoption of agriculture by humanity, and our understanding of medicine, science and the universe is a direct outcome of the societal stratification wrought by the agricultural ‘revolution’.

Dietary Imbalances of Cereal Grains

We all know that grains are certainly not a nutritional panacea. However, in addition to their obvious shortcomings, Cordain points to other lesser known deficiencies:

Many nutritionists consider cereal grains to be good sources of most of the B vitamins except for vitamin B12... of more importance is the biological availability of the B vitamins contained within cereal grains and their B vitamin content after milling, processing and cooking.

What he demonstrates, which most of us already knew, is that processing grains removes a lot of the vital nutrients contained within them. What most of us don't know, however, is that even if you include the outer coating of the grain (Whole Grain Products), a certain amount of processing and cooking is necessary to make them edible, which diminishes their nutritional content significantly. In addition to that, grains contain certain anti-nutrients that further diminish their nutritional quality:

Corn, like all cereal grains, is rich in antinutrients including lectins which are known to decrease intestinal absorption of many key nutrients.

Because of the high phytate content of whole grain cereals much of the calcium present is unavailable for absorption because the phytate forms insoluble complexes with calcium.

Antinutrients in Cereal Grains

Cordain uses this section to delve deeper into the source of antinutrients and their effect on humans:

...plants face an evolutionary tradeoff; they must grow fast enough to compete, yet they must
also divert enough energy for the synthesis of secondary metabolites required to ward off pathogens and herbivores. Defense is not the only role of secondary metabolites, and other functions include attraction of pollinators, protection from ultraviolet light, structural support, temporary nutrient storage, phytohormone regulation, facilitation of nutrient uptake and protection of roots from acidic and reducing environments.

Cereal grains which are the seeds of grasses (gramineae) contain a variety of secondary metabolites which can be either toxic, antinutritional, benign or somewhere in between, dependent upon the physiology of the consumer animal... Many birds, rodents, insects and ruminants can clearly consume cereal grains
in high quantities with minimal undue effects. Because primates evolved in the tropical forest, all of their potential plant food was derived from dicotyledonous species; therefore, the primate gut was initially adapted to both the
nutritive and defensive components of dicotyledons rather than the nutritive and defense components of monocotyledonous cereal grains... Consequently, humans, like all other primates have had little evolutionary experience in developing resistance to secondary
and antinutritional compounds which normally occur in cereal grains.


He then goes on to discuss the many antinutrients present in grains and their potential effects on humans. Most notable of these is:

Lectins - Lectins are proteins that are widespread in the plant kingdom with the unique property of binding to carbohydrate-containing molecules, particularly toward the sugar component. They were originally identified by their ability to agglutinate (clump) erythrocytes which occurs because of the interaction of multiple binding sites on the lectin molecule with specific glycoconjugate receptors on the surface of the erythrocyte cell membranes. Because of this binding property, lectins can interact with a variety of other cells in the body and are recognized as the major antinutrient of food.
The best studied of the cereal grain lectins is wheat germ agglutinin (WGA)
...there is suggestive evidence that high wheat gluten diets induce jejunal mucosal architectural changes in normal subjects without celiac disease
.
...Because of their resistance to digestive, proteolytic breakdown, the luminal concentrations of lectins can be quite high, consequently their transport through the gut wall can exceed that of other dietary antigens by several orders of magnitude. Additionally, WGA and other lectins, may facilitate the passage of undegraded dietary antigens into the systemic
circulation by their ability to increase the permeability of the intestine. Consequently, dietary lectins represent powerful oral immunogens capable of eliciting specific and high antibody responses.

The take-home message: Lectins are bad.

Autoimmune Diseases and Cereal Grain Consumption

Cordain attempts to explain the process of autoimmunity (lengthy and wordy), and then links grain consumption to the formation of various autoimmune diseases including Celiac Disease, Insulin-Dependent Diabetes Mellitus, and Rheumatoid Arthritis.

Conclusion

Frankly, after reading the entire paper numerous times, I realized that the majority of the information contained within is relatively useless to the average consumer, especially those of us who consume a supposedly "balanced" diet, and don't have an autoimmune disease. I think that most of the value in it can be obtained from reading just the conclusion. Cordain sums things up well:

From an evolutionary perspective, humanity’s adoption of agriculture, and hence cereal grain consumption, is a relatively recent phenomenon... Cereal grains represent a biologically novel food for mankind, consequently there is considerable genetic discordance between this staple food, and the foods to which our species is genetically adapted.
Cereal grains lack a number of nutrients which are essential for human health and well-being; additionally they contain numerous vitamins and minerals with low biological availability. Furthermore, the inability of humans to physiologically overcome cereal grain antinutrients (phytates, alkylresorcinols, protease inhibitors, lectins, etc.) is indicative of the evolutionary novelty of this food for our species. This genetic maladaptation between human nutrient requirements and those nutrients found in cereal grains manifests itself as vitamin and mineral deficiencies and other nutritionally related disorders, particularly when cereal grains are consumed in excessive quantity. More disturbing is the ability of cereal grain proteins (protease inhibitors, lectins, opioids and storage peptides) to interact with and alter human physiology.
Cereal grains obviously can be included in moderate amounts in the diets of most people without any noticeable, deleterious health effects, and herein lies their strength. When combined with a variety of both animal- and plantbased foods, they provide a cheap and plentiful caloric source, capable of sustaining and promoting human life. The ecologic, energetic efficiency wrought by the widespread cultivation and domestication of cereal grains
allowed for the dramatic expansion of worldwide human populations, which in turn, ultimately led to humanity’s enormous cultural and technological accomplishments. The downside of cereal grain consumption is their ability to disrupt health and well being in virtually all people when consumed in excessive quantity. This information has only been empirically known since the discovery of vitamins, minerals and certain antinutrients in the early part of this century.
Cereal grains are truly humanity’s double-edged sword. For without them, our species would likely have never evolved the complex cultural and technological innovations which allowed our departure from the hunter-gatherer niche. However, because of the dissonance between human evolutionary nutritional requirements and the nutrient content of these domesticated grasses, many of the world’s people suffer disease and dysfunction directly attributable to the consumption of these foods.

From personal experience, I find it much easier to control my body composition when I don't eat grains. Since it is easy to consume too many of them, and they don't provide me with anything that I can't obtain from a more nutritionally dense food source, I don't eat them. Also, since the potential interactions of many of the antinutrients present in grains are not well researched, I would rather not take any chances.

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

What is Functional Training?

Functional Training has become a popular catch phrase in the fitness industry. Personal trainers and coaches strive to make their programs functional to best serve the needs of their clients/athletes. You're likely to run across a number of different definitions and interpretations of functional training, but how are you to separate the truly knowledgeable from those who are just trying to keep up with the Jones'? I will attempt my definition and interpretation of this popular concept in the hopes of shedding some light on the issue.

If you look up functional in the dictionary, you are presented with the following definition:

Capable of serving the purpose for which it was designed.

Applied literally to training, this could mean anything. If the function of a bicep curl is to increase the strength of the biceps muscle, then yes, it is functional. If a client's goal is weight loss, then the protocol that does this the most effectively is arguably the most functional approach. In fact, any trainer that succeeds in having their clients meet their goals is arguably implementing functional training principles.

So if meeting your immediate goals is all you desire, then implementing functional training is easy. I encourage you to look a little deeper. What if, beyond getting stronger biceps, you also want to be able to use that biceps strength in a variety of real world activities? What if, beyond losing weight, you want to maintain the weight loss indefinitely and not burn out in the process? The definition of functional doesn't change, but the training method probably does. Those same bicep curls that produced massively strong biceps probably won't help you out when you need to pull yourself up over a ledge. Why? The principle of specificity provides some insight:

The training effect (change in performance level) on an individual as a result of performing any particular exercise or drill is very specific to the action practiced. The training effect can be expected to be different if the same action is practiced at a different speed, level of intensity, body position or under different environmental or psychological conditions.

What does that mean, you ask? Well, specifically, it means that performing bicep curls makes you better at performing bicep curls! Neuro-muscular pathways that you create are very specifically "learned", so trying to apply the biceps strength that you gained from doing bicep curls to any other exercise that is not a bicep curl, but involves the biceps muscle, will not produce the expected result of increased strength in that movement. The following statement from Rushall Thoughts sums this up well:

When training has occurred on a relatively simple activity, the benefits of that training are specific and do not transfer to more complex activities. Specific weight exercises do not cause improvements in the more complicated Olympic lifts (which, incidentally, require a high degree of complex skilled movement). Thus, when a coach considers auxiliary training exercises that are supposed to benefit a particular sport, if those exercises are simple, they will not be beneficial for an athlete. If they are performed with sustained intensity, they actually could prove to be counter-productive, primarily because of the development of unnecessary fatigue that could hinder more beneficial recovery.

Simply stated, in order to improve your performance at a given task, you must perform that task and/or tasks as closely related to that task as possible. Remember, it's all about neuro-muscular pathways. Your body remembers movements (like riding a bike) because it remembers the neuro-muscular connections, in sequence, that comprise the movement that it performed. The challenge then becomes determining which movement patterns are the most appropriate for your sport, and then designing your workout regimen around them.

Beyond sport we are left with the segment of the population that has no sport, that is interested in Functional Training for general health and/or injury prevention purposes. Luckily, we can use the same principles outlined above and apply them to your everyday life, your activities of daily living. The movement patterns most important in daily life are those that are going to encourage functional independence, that are going to keep you upright and physically able for the rest of your life. Your training program should consist only of those exercises that are going to improve your ability to perform activities of daily living, by closely mimicking movement patterns found in life. Crossfit founder Greg Glassman says it well in the CrossFit Foundations article:

There are movements that mimic motor recruitment patterns that are found in everyday life. Others are somewhat unique to the gym. Squatting is standing from a seated position; deadlifting is picking any object off the ground.They are both functional movements. Leg extension and leg curl both have no equivalent in nature and are in turn nonfunctional movements. The bulk of isolation movements are non-functional movements. By contrast the compound or multi-joint movements are functional. Natural movement typically involves the movement of multiple joints for every activity.

By creating a program that consists only of compound, multi-joint movements that mimic motor recruitment patterns found in everyday life, you are ensuring the most bang for your training buck. This is what defines functional training for me. If you can't think of a functional application of the exercise that you are performing in real life, then it's not functional. Plain and simple. That being said, I believe that the squat (free standing, see picture), is the MOST functional exercise you can perform. In my experience as a trainer, I have seen the most back pain relieved, knees healed, and improvements in performance from simply teaching my clients how to squat properly. It can take up to 3 years to fully develop a functionally sound squat, but trust me, it's worth it.

Monday, January 22, 2007

Workouts in the Meantime

Since I'm currently between clubs right now, and I would hate for any of my loyal clients to lose any progress, I will post a series of workouts that you can perform on your own until I figure my situation out.

Workout #1:

4 rounds:
400m run (or 3min on TM or other piece of cardio equipment)
15 Pullups (hanging rows if you can't pullup)
15 Box Jumps (step-ups if you can't jump)
15 Burpees (mountain climbers if you can't burpee)

Workout #2:

As Many Rounds in 20min:

6 Pushups
9 Swings
12 Jumping Pullups (holding bar entire time)

Workout #3:

21/18/15/12 reps:

Push Press (65# for men, 35# for women, or pick an appropriate weight)
Back Extension (supermans if you haven't done back extensions yet)
Knees to Elbows (just get your knees as high as you can, situps if you can't hang)
Dips (Jump to support if you can't dip, bench dips if you can't jump to support)
Deadlift (squat with medicine ball or weight between legs if you can't deadlift)

If you have any questions about any of these workouts, don't hesitate to email me, or you can ask Heather if you see her in the gym.

Tuesday, January 2, 2007

Soy, The New Corn

"Just imagine you could grow the perfect food. This food not only would provide affordable nutrition, but also would be delicious and easy to prepare in a variety of ways. It would be a healthful food, with no saturated fat. In fact, you would be growing a virtual fountain of youth on your back forty. This ideal food would help prevent, and perhaps reverse, some of the world's most dreaded diseases. You could grow this miracle crop in a variety of soils and climates. Its cultivation would build up, not deplete, the land. . . this miracle food already exists. . . It's called soy." This was written by Dean Houghton for The Furrow, a magazine published by the John Deere tractor company.

With 3/4 of all processed foods containing some form of soy in them these days, soybeans are quickly becoming a huge cash crop in the U.S., right behind corn, which is already in everything. Manufacturers have found ways to maximize the use of the bean, generating consumer goods from every part of the plant and by-products of all the steps of processing. Most of the public thinks of soy as a heath food, which is exactly how the soy industry wants it to be perceived. Is soy really good for you? Is it the miracle food that can reverse a host of disease states? This entry will attempt to shed some light on the issue.

A Brief History Of Soy Use

Soybeans first appeared for use during the Chou Dynasty (1134 - 246 BC) where they were not used for food, but frequently in crop rotation. Apparently the soy plant was initially used as a method of nitrogen fixing. The soybean did not serve as a food until the discovery of fermentation techniques, sometime late in the Chou Dynasty. The first soy foods were thus fermented products like tempeh, natto, miso and shoyu (soy or tamari sauce). At a later date, possibly in the 2nd century B.C., Chinese scientists discovered that a puree of cooked soybeans could be precipitated with calcium sulfate or magnesium sulfate (plaster of Paris or Epsom salts) to make a smooth pale curd - tofu or bean curd. The use of fermented and precipitated soy products soon spread to other parts of Asia, notably Japan and Indonesia. Although the highly flavored fermented products have elicited greater interest among scientists and epicures, it is the bland precipitated products that are most frequently used, accounting for approximately 90% of the processed soybeans consumed in Asia today. (The human genome adapts to new proteins, chemicals or toxins slowly. Since soy has only been used as a food source for a couple thousand years, it is not likely that our genes have adapted to massive soy consumption, given that grains have been consumed for roughly 10,000 years and celiac disease is still rampant in this country).
Large scale cultivation of the soybean in the United States began only after the Second World War. Most of the crop is made into animal feed and soy oil for hydrogenated fats (margarine and shortening). During the past 20 years, the industry has concentrated on finding markets for the byproducts of soy oil manufacture, including soy "lecithin", made from the oil sludge, and soy protein products, made from defatted soy flakes, a challenge that has involved overcoming consumer resistance to soy products, generally considered tasteless "poverty foods". "The quickest way to gain product acceptability in the less affluent society," said a soy industry spokesman, " ... is to have the product consumed on its own merit in a more affluent society." Hence the proliferation of soy products resembling traditional American foods: soy milk for cows milk, soy baby formula, soy yogurt, soy ice cream, soy cheese, soy flour for baking and textured soy protein as meat substitutes, usually promoted as high protein, low-fat, no cholesterol "healthfoods" to the upscale consumer increasingly concerned about his health. The growth of vegetarianism among the more affluent classes has greatly accelerated the acceptability and use of these ersatz products.


Is Soy Safe For Human Consumption?

  • Soybeans contain potent enzyme inhibitors which block the action of trypsin and other enzymes needed for protein digestion. They can produce serious gastric distress, reduced protein digestion and chronic deficiencies in amino acid uptake. In precipitated products, enzyme inhibitors concentrate in the soaking liquid rather than in the curd. Thus in tofu and bean curd, these enzyme inhibitors are reduced in quantity, but not completely eliminated.
  • Soybeans contain hemaglutinin, a clot promoting substance. Fermenting soybeans eliminates these substances.
  • Soybeans are high in phytic acid or phytates. This is an organic acid, present in the bran or hulls of all seeds, which blocks the uptake of essential minerals such as calcium, magnesium, iron and especially zinc in the intestinal tract. The soybean has a higher phytate content than any other grain or legume that has been studied. Furthermore, it seems to be highly resistant to many phytate reducing techniques such as long, slow cooking. Only a long period of fermentation will significantly reduce the phytate content of soybeans. Thus fermented products such as tempeh and miso provide nourishment that is easily assimilated, but the nutritional value of tofu and bean curd, both high in phytates, is questionable. When precipitated soy products are consumed with meat, the mineral blocking effects of the phytates are reduced. Vegetarians who consume tofu and bean curd as a substitute for meat and dairy products risk severe mineral deficiencies.
  • Much of soy today is genetically modified, which means that the gut has no history what-so-ever with such organisms. Therefore, the immune system, not recognizing such GM plants as foods, will treat such food antigens in the same manner it would an invasive virus, parasite, bacteria or fungi - it will try to eliminate it. Repeated exposure to such foodstuffs will sensitize the immune system, which may encourage autoimmune disorders.
  • Soybeans contain isoflavones callled genistein and daidzein. Isoflavones are one of two primary groups of phytoestrogens, plant-based estrogen mimicking organic chemicals with antioxidant properties. The safety of these estrogen mimics is questionable at best. While most of the soy industry claims that these chemicals prevent certain types of cancer, studies have actually shown them to promote cancer. Women with current or past breast cancer should be aware of the risks of potential tumor growth when taking soy products. Some studies indicate a correlation between a soy-rich diet and a decrease in testosterone levels in men, and have linked soy to male infertility. The safety of phytoestrogens present in soy infant formula has been repeatedly called into question, with studies linking soy formula consumption to a number of developmental disorders, including early onset of puberty in girls, learning disorders, lack of development of male sexual organs, asthma, thyroid disorders and irritable bowel syndrome. The bottom line is that the phytoestrogens in soy are endocrine disruptors because they mimic a horomone naturally found in the body. The soy industry argues that the level of phytoestrogens that must be consumed to make their effect physiologically significant is astronimically high. This seems like a valid arguement until one considers just how prevalent soy is in the food supply, making this physiologically significant level of consumption easily attainable. Levels of physiological significance vary per the individual, with some people displaying thyroid dysfunction with as little as 38mg of ingested isoflavones/day, which is less than the amount found in two glasses of soy milk, two servings of tofu, or a handful of soy nuts.
  • The process of producing soy protein isolate requires many processes that reduce the nutrient density and quality of the protein. In order to isolate the protein in soybeans from the carbohydrate and fatty acid components that naturally occur in the bean, they are first ground and subjected to high-temperature and solvent extraction processes to remove the oils. The resultant defatted meal is then mixed with an alkaline solution and sugars in a separation process to remove fiber. It is then precipitated and separated using an acid wash. Finally the resultant curds are neutralized in an alkaline solution and spray dried at high temperatures to produce high protein powder. This method destroys most of the anti-nutrients, but also denatures the proteins, rendering them difficult to digest and much reduced in effectiveness. The alkaline soaking solution produces a carcinogen, lysinealine, and reduces the cystine content, which is already low in the soybean. Lacking cystine, the entire protein complex of the soybean becomes useless unless the diet is fortified with cystine-rich meat, eggs, or dairy products.

Confused Yet?

If soybeans are so bad for you, then why is the soy industry relentlessly pushing the product as a health food, claiming numerous health benefits supposedly backed by scientific evidence? While I won't delve into the political and economical drivers behind this multi-billioin dollar industry, I will refute the most common argument FOR the safety of soy consumption: How can soy be bad for you if Asians have been and continue to consume massive quantities of the bean and all its products, yet display low incidence of most of the maladies that soy is supposed to cause?

Soy proponents claim that soy is a staple in Asia. A "staple" is defined as a major commodity, one that provides a large portion of calories in the diet, such as rice and fish in Japan, or rice and pork in China. The Japanese consume 150 pounds of fish per person per year, or almost one-half pound per person per day. A 1977 dietary survey in China determined that 65 percent of calories came from pork, including the pork fat used in cooking. By contrast, overall consumption of soy in Asia is surprisingly low. The average soy consumption in China is about 10 grams or 2 teaspoons per day. Levels are somewhat higher in Japan, averaging about 50 grams or 1/4 cup per day. In both countries, soy is used as a condiment or for flavoring, and not as a substitute for animal foods. Seafood and seaweed in the Japanese diet provide sufficient iodine to counteract the negative effects of the isoflavones in soy. The majority of soy products consumed in Asia are of the fermented type, containing the least amount of anti-nutrients. These levels of consumption amount to approximately 28mg of soy isoflavones per day. The lowest amount of isoflavones shown to cause endocrine dysfunction after just one month of consumption in American women is 45mg per day.

This post is by no means an exhaustive review of soy consumption and its relative risks. Information (backed by peer reviewed studies) is plentiful and free on the net. Here are a few resources where I pooled my information from that provide more information about soy than you ever thought you wanted to know. I urge you to educate yourself and come to your own conclusions:

http://www.mercola.com/article/soy/index.htm

http://www.westonaprice.org/soy/index.html

http://www.soyonlineservice.co.nz/

http://www.wholesoystory.com/

Thursday, December 28, 2006

Fast Health

As I mentioned in my Eating Simple post, I made some other pretty dramatic lifestyle changes 6 months ago besides switching the content of my diet to strictly paleo food. One of these changes was adopting a new eating schedule; I started intermittent fasting. What this means is that I started compressing my eating window, leaving 15-19 hours between my last and first meal. If I ate my last meal at 2pm, I wouldn't eat again until at least 5am the next morning. Why would anyone want to do this? Good question.

Scientists have known for years that caloric restriction (aka eating less) produces a plethora of health benefits, including lowered cholesterol, fasting glucose, and blood pressure. Studies on animals have even shown lifespan extension through caloric restriction. The problem is that the level of caloric restriction necessary to produce these benefits is difficult to implement long-term, resulting in increased irritability and depression. Restricting caloric intake also threatens to place the body in a catabolic state, promoting the degeneration of muscle tissue, including the heart. Gaining muscle in a catabolic state is next to impossible, and exercise is out of the question, because caloric restriction doesn't provide enough calories to support high levels of activity.

Fortunately, one can gain the benefits of caloric restriction through intermittent fasting, without having to restrict caloric intake. The landmark studies on IF were performed on animals, mostly rats and mice, in which they were divided into three groups: those that were fed ad libitum, those who ate a calorically restricted diet, and those that alternated between eating and fasting days. Results from these studies showed that the rats/mice that alternated between eating and fasting days ended up eating just as much as their ad libitum counterparts, but procured all of the health benefits that the caloric restriction group did. A few studies have been performed on humans, and the results look promising:

Effect of intermittent fasting and refeeding on insulin action in healthy men

Neuroprotective potential of the Bahadori leanness program: A "mini-fast with exercise" strategy.

Effects of intermittent fasting on serum lipid levels, coagulation status and plasma homocysteine levels.

My own experience with IF has been great. When I'm following an IF eating schedule, I have more energy, sleep better, and have reduced cravings compared to when I'm not IFing. I also notice that it's easier to lean out when I'm IFing, and I perform better in workouts. I've never found the eating schedule difficult to maintain, as long as I make it through the initial 2-3 days.

If you think about this from an evolutionary perspective, IF was probably the way Paleolithic man ate. Society has taught us that we should be eating 3 meals/day. Current nutritional science preaches the 5 small meals throughout the day dogma, leaving no more than 4 hours between each meal. Animals in the wild, particularly carnivorous animals, don’t eat this way. They eat when they kill, and I would think that Paleolithic man did the same. I would think that a day in the life of Paleolithic man would look something like this: hunt down and kill animal (exercise), gorge on animal (post-workout meal), sleep, repeat when hungry. Data gathered from humans still living in non-Westernized cultures in the last century supports this theory. The theory behind the Paleo diet is that it is the optimal diet for us today because it is the diet we were molded by the forces of natural selection to perform best on. If you believe that, then you should probably believe that a Paleolithic eating schedule is also optimal.

Wednesday, December 13, 2006

Protein?

It's a prevailing topic in most strength and conditioning circles, a great concern to athletes in general, and I'm sure the rest of the populace has thought about it at one time or another: How much protein do I need? The answer is anything but simple, and I wouldn't dare suggest that I'm qualified to give out that kind of advice. What I do offer is a synopsis of a debate that I recently read from The Performance Menu on this very topic:


THE PROTEIN DEBATE
Loren Cordain, PhD & T. Colin Campbell, PhD

Protein plays a litany of roles in living systems: structural elements, peptide hormones, cell recognition, antibodies… the list is staggering and continues to grow as our understanding of biology expands. What, however, is the role of dietary protein in health and disease in humans? Is the source, type and quantity intimately and directly tied to optimal physical development and continued wellbeing? Is it causative or preventative of disease? How do we know, and how can we know? One would think this question should be straightforward and easily answered; as you will soon see the question is anything but simple! In the pages that follow, two scientists at the top of their respective fields—Dr. T. Colin Campbell, Jacob Gould Schurman Professor Emeritus of Nutritional Biochemistry at Cornell University, author of The China Study and Dr. Loren Cordain Professor, Department of Health & Exercise Science, Colorado State University, author of The Paleo Diet—make their competing cases for the role of dietary protein in health and disease.

Full text article available for free download


Warning!! Spoilers!! Only read on if you have read the article (or if you don't want to read the article and just want to know what I think about it)

In my opinion, Cordain owned Campbell in this debate. Campbell's arguments were weak and unsubstantiated (he provided absolutely no references), and his protein recommendations were based on the assumption that the only physiological significance of protein is to replenish excreted nitrogen. He attacked animal protein as the cause of numerous diseases, without providing a shred of evidence as to why that's so. Cordain's discussion about the evolutionary basis for the therapeutic effects of high protein diets was informative and well written. While I don't agree with everything that Cordain has to say, mostly surrounding saturated fat (another great topic for a future post), I find his insights compelling, and he always backs up whatever he has to say with numerous references that are easily accessible. A few highlights from the debate:

"...it should be noted that there is a physiological limit to the amount of protein that can be ingested before it becomes toxic. A byproduct of dietary protein metabolism is nitrogen, which in turn is converted into urea by the liver and then excreted by the kidneys into the urine. The upper limit of protein ingestion is determined by the liver’s ability to synthesize urea. When nitrogen intake from dietary protein exceeds the ability of the liver to synthesize urea, excessive nitrogen (as ammonia) spills into the bloodstream causing hyperammonemia and toxicity. Additionally excess amino acids from the metabolism of high amounts of dietary protein may become toxic by entering the circulation causing hyperaminoacidemia."

Sounds like a pretty good determinant for how much protein is too much, doesn't it? Dr. Campbell didn't think so:

"If this is an inference that all could be well until this limit is reached, it is grossly misleading."

I don't think that Cordain ever meant to infer that all is well up to this limit of protein consumption. In fact, he goes on to say that this level of protein consumption is unrealistic to expect in all but the most drastic situations, such as when humans were forced to rely upon the fat depleted, lean meat of wild animals in times of harsh weather conditions and resource scarcity. His protein recommendations are genetically based, pulling from isotopic fossil and ethnographic evidence, and he concludes that:

"The evolutionary evidence indicates that so called “high protein diets” (20 – 30 % total energy) and “very high protein diets” (30- 40 % total energy) actually represent the norm which conditioned the present day human genome over more than 2 million years of evolutionary experience. The evolutionary template would predict that human health and well being will suffer when dietary intakes fall outside this range... There is now a large body of experimental evidence increasingly demonstrating that a higher intake of lean animal protein reduces the risk for cardiovascular disease, hypertension, dyslipidemia, obesity, insulin resistance, and osteoporosis while not impairing kidney function."

And now, Campbell's recommendations:

"Probably the simplest method of determining recommended intakes, at least conceptually, has been the N balance study. An experimental determination is made of how much protein, analyzed according to its N content, must be consumed in order to compensate for the average daily amount of N lost from the body. After adjusting for the 16% N content of protein and after adjusting upward the experimental mean by two standard deviations to include the needs of about 98% of the larger population, this gives an ‘allowance’, or recommendation, of 0.8 gm of protein to be consumed per day per kg of body weight, for both sexes... The question, then, should not be how much protein is needed but how much protein in excess of the 10% dietary level can be safely consumed."

That's it. Protein is nothing but a nitrogen vehicle, and extreme caution should be used when handling it. Cordain's response:

"nitrogen balance studies have been extensively used to predict the minimal human protein requirements. Because all protein contains 16.6% nitrogen, then the measurement of nitrogen serves as a proxy for protein. Colin’s argument is that optimal health occurs when we are in zero nitrogen balance (e.g. when our daily nitrogen intake = daily nitrogen excretion), and that excessive protein intake and hence negative nitrogen balance (nitrogen intake <>minimal protein requirements provide no information about optimal protein requirements."

And this is where I think that Cordain has hit the nail on the head. Where as Campbell seeks to demonize protein (particularly animal-based) and claim that it is the cause of numerous diseases when consumed in excess (which he provides zero evidence for), Cordain attempts to establish parameters for optimal protein requirements, based on the success of peoples with no influences over what to eat except for what was available to them and what their DNA told them was right (WARNING, oversimplification).

I have to admit, I consider myself an evolutionary biologist. Although I have no formal education on the topic (I have read some really good books on the topic however), it's just what makes the most sense to me. Because of this, my opinions are in no way an objective analysis of this debate.

Tuesday, December 12, 2006

Eating Simple

Approximately 6 months ago, I walked into the charting office at the PRO Club and exclaimed, frustrated: "Why am I always hungry?! I'm eating almost 4000kcal/day, but it's not enough! I think about food all day!" To my surprise, I received a response, from at that time an unlikely candidate, Heather Gibbons: "What are you eating?"

I had been working at the PRO Club for about 1 1/2 years at this point, and I was fairly certain that I had my nutrition figured out. Through what I had learned in University in the few nutrition courses that I had taken, plus wisdom that I had gained through training clients in the club's metabolic disorders program, I was certain that I was eating an effective and highly nutritious diet. I ate 5 small meals/day, dispersed every 4 hours, with each meal consisting of approximately equal parts carbohydrate, protein, and fat (or so I thought, I really wasn't that diligent). I ate plenty of vegetables, fruits, lean protein, low-fat dairy, and whole grains. I limited my saturated fat and sugar intake, and tried to stay away from highly processed foods (although I never really questioned what it meant to be processed). The problem was, with all that I had learned, through implication, I wasn't seeing the results that I had come to expect. Although I was by no means overweight, I still had some annoying abdominal fat that I couldn't get rid of, I felt soft, and I was never satiated. I was frustrated, and willing at this point to accept a radical paradigm shift. Luckily for me, that shift was about to land on my lap, as Heather introduced me to the Paleo Diet.

The Paleo Diet, created by Dr. Loren Cordain, is based on the concept that the optimal diet for ideal body weight, optimal health, and peak athletic performance is one consistent with human genetic evolution. What does this mean in practice? Very simply, if it wasn't available to man prior to the Agricultural Revolution (approximately 500 generations ago, a blink of an eye by evolutionary standards), it shouldn't be eaten. This means no refined sugar, no processed food, no dairy, no grain, no legumes. The diet consists of lean meats, seafood, fruits, vegetables, and nuts.

The results that I saw were sudden and drastic. My energy levels increased and remained consistent throughout the day, I slept better, my hunger was manageable, and I lost approximately 20 pounds in a mere 6 weeks (I made some other dramatic changes to my lifestyle at this point, which I will discuss in future posts, but for the time being I would like to focus on the benefits of the Paleo Diet).

The mechanism through which the diet provides it's benefit is fairly simple: by eliminating foods from your diet that your body more than likely isn't equipped to digest properly, you optimize the health of your digestive system, improving the quality of your digestion. Combined with the fact that you are eliminating nutritionally sparse, calorically dense foods from your diet and replacing them with nutritionally dense foods, it's easy to see how and why the diet works so well.

Cordain, a member of the faculty of the Department of Health and Exercise Science at Colorado State University, has been researching the effects of diet on human health and specifically the links between modern diet and disease for the past 20 years. His published research is impressive, and I recommend that anyone interested in achieving optimal health at least browse though it.

When trying to grasp the concept of the Paleo Diet, don't get caught up in semantics. The value lies not in constantly questioning "would paleo man do this?" or "what would paleo man do in this situation?", relying on the diet as THE answer to all of your nutritional questions. The diet serves best as a template for determining food quality standards. The timing of meals and quantity of macronutrients that you should be consuming is governed by other concepts, which will be discussed in future posts.